Editorial: Organs seized from inmates for sale in China

COMMENTARY
Editorial: Organs seized from inmates for sale in China

Editorial, ST. LOUIS POST-DISPATCH
Friday, August 25, 2006

Thousands of Americans travel overseas every year to get low-cost medical
care or treatment. A relative handful find their way to China, where for the
right price — as much as $130,000 for a liver or $160,000 for a heart —
organs are available for transplantation.

It's no secret that many of those organs have come from executed prisoners.
But there is growing evidence that many are now being obtained from people
whose only crime was to practice a form of meditation and exercise called
Falun Gong.

MOST POPULAR STORIES

   * Fight at Stony Point High School
   * Attack launched on UT's new Godzillatron!
   * Defensive ends drop pounds with eyes on QBs
   * Tokyo Subway to Display Naked Spears Ad
   * Youngest players shouldn't have much of an impact for Texas

This week, St. Louis Post-Dispatch reporter Deborah L. Shelton documented
the case of Huangui Li, 62, who was arrested for distributing banned
literature in 2001. Li, a former mathematics teacher now living in Maryland
Heights, Mo., says she was taken to a medical facility for tests to judge
her suitability for organ donation. She believes her high blood pressure
saved her life.

Many Americans have difficulty accepting the claims of Li and others with
similar stories to tell. Removing organs from a live human being for
transplanting into a wealthy foreigner seems like a horror movie plot. But
an international investigation led by a former member of Canada's parliament
concluded last month that "there has been and continues to be the
large-scale seizure of organs from unwilling Falun Gong practitioners."

Among evidence cited in the report are statements by the wife of a surgeon
who removed the corneas of about 2,000 Falun Gong practitioners between 2001
and 2003. It also cites statements by officials at detention centers in
Shanghai, Shandong and the provinces of Guandong, Shaanxi, Sichuan, Henan
and Hubei. Some admitted that organs came from Falun Gong practitioners;
others simply referred to the availability of "live, beating hearts" or
"young, healthy kidneys." As many as 41,500 organs transplanted in China
from 2000 to 2005 may have come from prisoners, including Falun Gong
practitioners, the report notes.

Many of those who visit China in search of organ transplants come from Asia.
But as Shelton reported, some Americans are making the trip. "We did what we
needed to do, and we did everything legally," the wife of one transplant
recipient notes on her blog.

Growing numbers of American transplant surgeons report seeing patients who
have had Chinese organ transplants. Officials from the United Network for
Organ Sharing, which coordinates donations and transplants in the United
States, issued a formal statement last month decrying transplant tourism, in
which an American travels overseas to buy an organ from a poor person in the
developing world. It already is illegal to buy an organ in this country, as
it is in the rest of the developed world.

Congress should go one step further. It should make it illegal for Americans
to travel overseas for transplants in any country where credible evidence
shows forced donation or organ sales. After hearings at which evidence of
prisoners being forced to donate organs was presented in 2001, Congress
moved to ban Chinese transplant surgeons from receiving additional training
in the United States. After the 9/11 attacks, the measure died. It should be
revived.

Many people would be willing to go a long way to save their own lives or
that of a loved one. But traveling to China, where someone may be coerced or
executed to provide organs for transplant, is beyond the pale.

http://www.statesman.com/opinion/content/editorial/stories/08/25editorialedit.html